Sixty-40Play

28 January 2021: Robinhood stops the GameStop rally

At the height of the meme-stock frenzy, Robinhood and several other brokers restricted buying of GameStop, AMC and other heavily traded stocks, citing clearinghouse collateral demands. GameStop fell sharply that day, and retail traders were furious, suspecting the rules had been changed to protect hedge funds. Congress held hearings. The episode taught a generation that the plumbing of markets matters as much as the price.

The lesson: Your broker's balance sheet and risk limits can matter as much as your own investment thesis.

What it meant for investors

$1,000 in GameStop at the start of 2020 → $16,667 today, vs $2,092 in the S&P 500.

We start the clock at the start of 2020, the latest year on the wheel. That is 16.7 times the money, and $14,574 more than a plain index fund made over the same years.

What GameStop teaches: Crowded short positions can produce explosive squeezes, but price spikes driven by flows rather than fundamentals rarely persist for late buyers.

Bought inPrice thenWorth todayS&P 500 would be
2015$8.50$2,941$3,301
2018$4.50$5,556$2,519
2020$1.50$16,667$2,092

green = beat the S&P 500 · red = lost money

What if you bought GameStop? Every starting year and the full story →

28 January 2021: Robinhood stops the GameStop rally